Pros:
Open layout, plenty of room, friendly staff, amazing city and ocean views, walkable location, beautiful architecture, historic charm, refreshing pool, great price, resident bat (at the time of our trip)
Cons:
Old/ outdated furniture, hard beds (but you get used to them), leaks in the ceiling/roof in the living room and upper room, cold water in the upper bathroom, and all the other pieces of "character" that come with an old building
Overall:
This place is great! I'd recommend it to anyone, especially groups.